One of the
most polarized issues in politics today is directly involved with women’s
sexuality: abortion. We’ve touched briefly on abortion in class, talking about
who’s decision it is and why. As Kentucky’s last abortion clinic fights to remain
open this week, I thought this topic might deserve some attention.
Abortion has been a polarizing
issue since the 1973 Roe v. Wade
decision. When the Supreme Court agreed that women had the right to an abortion
under the 14th amendment, it changed how states were able to
regulate abortions. After 1973, they could only regulate them during the second
and third trimesters of pregnancy. Abortion has long been regarded, at least by
the liberals, as a woman’s reproductive right.
While birth control has become more accessible to women over time, it is
not always effective. That can leave a woman in a bind, with an unplanned and
unwanted pregnancy. Even before abortion was legalized, many women had
unauthorized abortions. These procedures were not always safe, making some
women sterile and sometimes causing a woman to die from complications. By
legalizing abortion, it has allowed the medical profession to step in and
safely preform these procedures, causing the complication and mortality rates
to go down.
However, there is still a large opposition to legalized abortion,
including the very prevalent religious conservatives. Part of this can be seen
by how few hospitals perform abortions and how many abortion clinics are in
each state. For example, in Kentucky many of the hospitals are affiliated with
religious groups. In Louisville, some of the major hospitals include Baptist
Health, Jewish, and St. Mary’s and Elizabeth. Most hospitals affiliated with religious
groups or donors refuse to perform abortions unless the life of the mother is
in immediate danger. This makes it difficult for women to have access to
abortion, which is where the clinics step in.
Abortion clinics are contentious in nature. They are there to perform the
surgery the hospital might disagree with. However, they might have to have
contracts with local hospitals for emergency transportation and admission of
their patient in case something goes wrong. This makes it harder for clinics to
exist, especially in states with a large conservative population.
In the past few weeks, Kentucky’s last abortion clinic’s future has been
up in the air. Governor Matt Bevin’s administration told the EMW Women’s
Surgical Center they lacked the proper agreements with local hospitals for
patient care in case of emergency, even though the agreements were approved
last year. The clinic sued to stay open, claiming it was an attempt to ban
abortion in Kentucky. This would impact many women’s ability to access an abortion,
mimicking the lack of access to birth control in the past.
I work in downtown Louisville and I have to pass the EMW Women’s Surgical
Center on my way. Last Saturday, in the wake of the attempt to close it and the
lawsuit, there were more protesters than usual. They had graphic signs about
the “horrors” of abortion. There were also more volunteers that escort women
into the building than I’ve seen recently at the building, at least 20. While
abortion might not seem like a direct issue in sexuality, it is when women have
little options concerning both birth control and abortion. Accessibility has
been a constant struggle we looked at throughout class, and this is yet another
way to make medical help that deals with sexuality less accessible.
Here's the link to the Courier Journal article about the EMW Women's Surgical Center:
http://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/politics/2017/03/29/kys-last-abortion-clinic-sues-stay-open/99412244/
Here's the link to the Courier Journal article about the EMW Women's Surgical Center:
http://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/politics/2017/03/29/kys-last-abortion-clinic-sues-stay-open/99412244/
Abortion is such a tricky issue because it’s one of the few controversies that nearly everyone has a strong opinion on, and more than likely isn’t going to reach a compromise. On one side of the argument, banning abortion takes control away from women to make decisions about their bodies, and on the other hand, keeping abortion legal goes directly against religious beliefs which bestow the right to life. This makes it almost impossible to argue because it doesn’t really matter what kind of concrete evidence you provide for the necessity of legal and safe abortion—if someone doesn’t believe you, then your argument is usually automatically invalid. As I’m sure many of us have seen, anti-abortion advocates grace the sidewalks of WKU during the warmer months and carry huge signs depicting graphic botched abortions, often using pictures of abortions that occurred late enough during the pregnancy that the fetus has actually begun to resemble a small human. Does it really matter that these photos represent the extremely small percentage of people that have abortions that late during pregnancy? Does it really matter that the gruesomeness of those photos is a more accurate depiction of an unsafe botched abortion than a safe and legal one? I guess not since the legality of abortions seems to be hanging by a legislative thread.
ReplyDeleteIt’s probably not hard to tell that I’m a little bitter by the way in which constitutionality seems to be ignored when it comes to protecting the rights of women to take control of their bodies. I work as a crisis advocate for rape and sexual assault victims, and have seen situations in which medical professionals either refuse to provide or lie about their ability to provide emergency contraceptive such as Plan B—even though emergency contraceptive comes standard with any rape kit and it’s against the law to deny a survivor access to anything within a rape kit. It’s stories like this which makes me angry—abortion is not an “easy way out” like so many make it out to be.
I’m very riled up about this now, but on to my main point: just like with any system, especially those that provide services to others, there are going to be people that abuse it, but that doesn’t mean that the majority of people taking advantage of the service aren’t coming from a place of need. I’m not saying that having abortion laws and procedures are perfect, or that everyone will be howdy-dandy by having abortion remain legal, but if we’re worried about the destruction of life maybe we should take a second to think about all the ways women can be gravely injured during an unsafe and unregulated abortion procedure. Abortions aren’t going to stop regardless of what law is put in place, but we have the ability to regulate them so that they don’t hurt the women seeking them.